What do you think?

Is the medical profession only for the well-off?
False
News & media
Is the medical profession only for the well-off?
Debate current medical affairs
Alan Milburn (the government's social mobility tsar) has criticised the medical profession for not doing enough to open its doors to poorer students. In a new report, he "will urge teaching hospitals
2
Cat:OffDutyForum:NewsMedia
Cat:OffDutyForum:NewsMediaDiscussion:839685df-d388-4819-9ed3-f414bb63d7c7

Forums » Off duty » News & media » Is the medical profession only for the well-off?

You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 
 First << 1 2 3
Forums  »  Off duty  »  News & media  »  Is the medical profession only for the well-off?

Re: Is the medical profession only for the well-off?

posted at 5/6/2012 4:34 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 16
First: 10/1/2009
Last: 30/1/2013
Being part of the profession and being from a less well off background I would say no. As I am sure would most of my colleagues. 

Yet I know that many of my patients and friends from where I grew up would say yes. There are many reasons for this. 

Doctors are seen as the high fliers of society (one of them anyway) and many people see social mobility as somehow taboo or very difficult. I can certainly vouch for the fact that social mobility is difficult. When I went to university I felt many fellow students did not want to know me as I did not have family connections, or able to go on holidays, go out all the time to the best clubs or do a wonder of things that required wealth of some description. I clearly remember saying I had no money to a friend (meaning I had about £2 in the bank until my next loan cheque went in and they were trying to convince me to go out as I would only be spending £10 or so. In addition to this I found it very difficult to relate to many people from home who did not go to uni, someone who has a job as a check out assistant can feel that they are very different to someone who is studying to be a doctor (even if that medical student does that job every summer). 

Second, the actuall going to university is seen as prohibitive to many from less well off backgrounds. Telling people they have to get into debt (however that debt is paid back) is going to put a large number of people off when the only experience they have with debt is that of their parents who may not have had the best time paying it back. 

Finally, for many families losing a member who could contribute to the family income to uni where they may end up needing to empty the family coffers more is out of the question. 

No matter how much we encourage poeple to apply to university, this isn't going to change. Unless we pay people to equivelant of a living wage to study (for everyone and not dissadvantage those on middle incomes) and do not charge tuition fees these factors are always going to play a part.

Re: Is the medical profession only for the well-off?

posted at 7/6/2012 12:30 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 6
First: 11/11/2010
Last: 7/6/2012
I don't think it is entirey true as I am the first doctor in my family. I must admit though that a significant number of my classmates in med school were one way or the other related to a doctor. The trend has even taken an even worse turn with the introduction of full fee paying option in Ghana. People from the supposedly middle class background like us doctors may not be able to afford the cost of medical education for our wards should they miss the little room left for students to enter on merit. If the current trend continues in Ghana at least, i can imagine that the answer to the question will be a big YES!
 First << 1 2 3

Forums » Off duty » News & media » Is the medical profession only for the well-off?