What do you think?

Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?
False
Medical mums
Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?
Combining parenthood with a career in medicine often presents unique challenges. Medical mums enables you to share your experiences and to learn from others who are going through similar situations first hand. Our community of medical mums post topics that you might want to discuss, but you're free to talk about any subject you like.<br /> <br /> If you want help regarding your personal situation, you can speak to the BMA on 0300 123 1233<br />
When doctors were expected to work 36 hour shifts or 72 hours weekends one had some sympathy with those who withdrew from night work at a late stage of pregnancy. Now that junior doctors are limited t
0
Cat:OffDutyForum:ac2e6699-a9bc-4d2d-a680-cc2d09d3be2c
Cat:OffDutyForum:ac2e6699-a9bc-4d2d-a680-cc2d09d3be2cDiscussion:3cbe7cfd-65e2-4b06-aa2b-22191bfc1bcc

Forums » Off duty » Medical mums » Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 
Forums  »  Off duty  »  Medical mums  »  Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

posted at 9/6/2012 12:22 PM BST on bmj.com
Moved from the General clinical forum
Posts: 11
First: 31/8/2009
Last: 9/6/2012
When doctors were expected to work 36 hour shifts or 72 hours weekends one had some sympathy with those who withdrew from night work at a late stage of pregnancy. Now that junior doctors are limited to a 48 hour week and work shifts, they appear still to feel they have the right, sometimes from 20 weeks, to withdraw themselves from night or weekend work. The nursing staff, who work similar shifts, albeit for fewer hours, do not have this right. In my region, no-one has had the courage to tell them this is unreasonable. Is it? What do other regions do?

Re: Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

posted at 12/6/2012 6:27 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 16
First: 10/1/2009
Last: 30/1/2013
I stopped working nights after i became I'll on a nightshift at 20 weeks. My body told me to slow down, not me. I found at a later date (in a job where the rota coordinator did not give me any long shifts (which ruled out nights and weekends) I was far more tired doing my duties than my colleagues. I think that if my hours could not have been altered (but still 43 1/2 hours a week) then I would have left to go on leave much earlier.

Re: Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

posted at 12/6/2012 7:22 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 312
First: 2/6/2012
Last: 10/5/2013
it should be allowed.

Re: Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

posted at 13/6/2012 5:50 AM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 19
First: 15/2/2012
Last: 11/7/2012
i think it is helpful to a pregant doctor for giving up  on a nightshift after  28  weeks,tension  work will  be not  beneficial for fetus growing.

Re: Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

posted at 13/6/2012 7:51 AM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 50
First: 5/3/2010
Last: 23/1/2013
yes

Re: Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?

posted at 21/6/2012 5:51 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 2
First: 21/6/2012
Last: 21/6/2012
In Response to Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?:
When doctors were expected to work 36 hour shifts or 72 hours weekends one had some sympathy with those who withdrew from night work at a late stage of pregnancy. Now that junior doctors are limited to a 48 hour week and work shifts, they appear still to feel they have the right, sometimes from 20 weeks, to withdraw themselves from night or weekend work. The nursing staff, who work similar shifts, albeit for fewer hours, do not have this right. In my region, no-one has had the courage to tell them this is unreasonable. Is it? What do other regions do?
Posted by FionaC


As a 23 week pregnant SHO i do not think this is unreasonable. Where i work pregnant women do not automatically stop working out of hours after 20 weeks they have to have an occupational health assesment if they themselves or HR feel they are no longer able to do out of hours. I am shocked and disgusted by the negative and in many cases purely ignorant opinions my work colleagues have expressed about the fact that i no longer work out of hours. I do wonder why the entered a caring profession. Also i don't feel that anyone that has not been pregnant themselves can have a realistic opinion on the matter and should reserve judgement until they have been through it themselves.

Forums » Off duty » Medical mums » Should pregnant doctors be able to stop working "unsocial hours"?