What do you think?

Was I unprofessional?
False
General
Was I unprofessional?
Discuss non-medical topics
The Scene, The pre-operative anaesthesia assessment visit. The Patient. A man in his 50s, for intermediate orthopaedic surgery.  He is obese (BMI 36), has hypertension and epilepsy controlled on
3
Cat:OffDutyForum:General
Cat:OffDutyForum:GeneralDiscussion:dc383215-a559-449c-9512-f7d231aee677

Forums » Off duty » General » Was I unprofessional?

You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 
 First << 1 2 3 4
Forums  »  Off duty  »  General  »  Was I unprofessional?

Re: Was I unprofessional?

posted at 26/7/2012 6:58 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 1
First: 26/7/2012
Last: 26/7/2012
No you not unprofessional.  I would have stopped right there and ask them to go elsewhere. Just like you don't yell I have a bomb on a plane you don't tell the physician/dentist if something does go wrong I will sue.  That is not how I wish to be treated.  I would have decline to do the proceedure. 

Re: Was I unprofessional?

posted at 27/7/2012 1:28 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 50
First: 5/3/2010
Last: 23/1/2013
In Response to Re: Was I unprofessional?:
No you not unprofessional.  I would have stopped right there and ask them to go elsewhere. Just like you don't yell I have a bomb on a plane you don't tell the physician/dentist if something does go wrong I will sue.  That is not how I wish to be treated.  I would have decline to do the proceedure. 
Posted by khafner


Could not agree more. You were extremely professional. Drs are expected to tolerate any rudeness and expected to say nothing..You should have refused to anaesthetise this patient.

Re: Was I unprofessional?

posted at 31/7/2012 6:03 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 958
First: 15/7/2011
Last: 15/5/2013

John, I have just spent several hours discussing with a client whose neurological and cognitive function would best be described as 'two neurones joined by a spirochaete'. As I get older I am becoming less patient not more. Why is this Doctor?

Re: Was I unprofessional?

posted at 31/7/2012 8:56 PM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 2034
First: 12/3/2010
Last: 17/5/2013
For some people's brains, thinking is like those ball puzzles you shake about until the one falls into the hole. Sometimes a jolly good shake helps it in.

John

Re: Was I unprofessional?

posted at 1/8/2012 12:31 AM BST on bmj.com
Posts: 15
First: 8/5/2009
Last: 19/4/2013
Hi John,
You were very professional.  The patient's wife may have been worried, but she can't makethrow away remarks .  She may have sued if you damaged his teeth.  It's better them to know potential problems than not to know.
In Response to Was I unprofessional?:
The Scene, The pre-operative anaesthesia assessment visit. The Patient. A man in his 50s, for intermediate orthopaedic surgery.  He is obese (BMI 36), has hypertension and epilepsy controlled on drugs, smokes 10-15/day (allegedly)  and has bad teeth.   He also has a partner/wife with him who interjects all the time. The Scenario. I tell the man how I intend to anaesthetise him (GA, TCI, LA for post op, analgesia).   I also say that I will do my best to avoid damage to his teeth, in the course of maintaining his airway. The wife cuts in, "Then we'll sue you!" I glare. "Ha-ha! Only joking!  We're a bit nervous" I say that I am not joking, I take my job very seriously, and that I hope that they will too.  I give a short lecture on the risks of anaesthesia with special reference to the airway.   I conclude my visit, having obtained the man's verbal consent (all that we do in the UK). He arrives in theatre, calm, and his anaesthetic and operation go smoothly. But In theatre and later on the ward, the staff all ask me, "What DID you say to that woman?!?"    Apparently, she stormed out just after I had gone, very clearly very angry. Reflection. She had already irritated me by her constant prodding and correcting of her husbands replies to my questions.    I have been threatened before with being sued for tooth damage.  Then and now, I warn the patient and document it, but no one likes being sued. She may have been worried, for her husband, and I should have made allowance. The patient was not straightforward, and I wasn't expecting to enjoy his case. so another reason for being snappy. But was I unprofessional?  Should I have ignored her remark as being irrelevant to the patient's care? John
Posted by John D

 First << 1 2 3 4

Forums » Off duty » General » Was I unprofessional?