What do you think?

Most popular blogs

Latest blog posts

Blog Image
Thoughts and insights from medical students
A medical student's dirty little secret
QOFs buy Porsches!! GPs don't do any real work, all they do is refer. GPs don't practice real medicine.

Why the hell would you want to be a GP?

I'm not sure about you, but there seems to be a lot of stigma around medical students wanting to be GPs where I am. From personal experience, my partner wants to be a GP and his mother (who is a secretary for an orthopaedic surgeon) was horrified to find out he wanted to be a GP and started reeling off a long list of specialities that "he has yet to experience". She viewed GPs as second rate doctors and only "doctors who couldn't make consultants become GPs". I've also witnessed hospital consultants pulling a face and saying why would you want to do that to students who have confessed to being interested in general practice.

Personally, being a GP has never come very high on my list of career choices, in fact it's always been pretty low & more than a few times I can recall saying never, ever! So why is it that every student seems to dream of being a surgeon / cardiologist / A&E consultant / neurosurgeon etc etc? Why is it almost seen as a dirty secret that we aspire to become general practitioners? (Of course, this could completely not be the case where you are, but that seems to be the attitude here.)

In fact, I had a moment on GP placement the other week and it left me feeling so good that I thought I'd share.

The patient was an older gentleman who had come in with his wife after being discharged from hospital recently due to gallstones. He was awaiting an ERCP and had been sent home with a prescription for regular paracetamol and co-amoxiclav.

The paracetamol label read, take 2 tablets, 4 times a day and the co-amoxiclav take 1 tablet 3 times a day.

The couple were very anxious as the patient felt he did not know how to correctly take his medication, would it interact with his other medications, should they be taken in conjunction with food etc. From a knowledge perspective, these questions are quite easily addressed and didn't take a lot of time. The couple just wanted some reassurance and guidance.

Additionally the patient was very concerned as he had a friend pass away from septicaemia secondary to gallstones. He was very concerned about the possibility of that happening to him and how he would know he had an "infection of the blood". Again, this seemed like a concern that was could easily and quickly be addressed.

Anyway, this experience actually changed my opinion of general practice radically. Whatever the reason, the patient didn't get the information and reassurance he needed from the hospital doctors and as a GP we could discuss his concers and he left feeling quite satisfied. I just got a great deal of satisfaction from the fact that we were able to help him and reassure him and his partner; it was rather lovely!

So maybe general practice has moved just a little higher up my list of career choices...either way I think I'll keep that revelation to myself for now!
Tags:
Email this post
User Image
Joey Rio wrote:
As I see there is a lot of prejudice regarding the GPs almost everywhere.

My guess is that this is money-driven.

Albeit being a specialist I find the GPs as the best doctors for dealing withe the complexities of a patient´s life, beyond their diseases.

Specialist should only come over, focally, in secondary and terciary prevention issuesand then return the individual to the better&broader whole healthcare provided by a good GP.

All Best,

Joey
18/1/2012 8:15 PM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
Odysseus wrote:
The GP is the conductor, the specialists play the various instruments according to temperament, while the patient is the score. The result should be a harmonious symphony with a dignified coda.

My late father was a dedicated solo GP all his life. He was a thorough and insightful diagnostician, compassionate and long-suffering but not with fools. I wrote a book about this life. See my personal details on this site for that.

A vocationally-trained country GP in Australia attracts nothing but admiration from me.
19/1/2012 3:10 AM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
Odysseus wrote:
I would not say your secret is dirty unless you have such a poor attitude to general practice. It sounds a little snobbish to use such an expression. As a specialist I hold GPs at the same level as I. I don't subscribe to a medical caste system.
19/1/2012 3:35 AM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
skyesteve wrote:
The solution to all this is simple and semantic in my view. I would be happy to be called a Consultant in Primary and Intermediate Care instead - because that's what I am in the end of the day.
20/1/2012 1:26 PM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
Tom Koch wrote:
It's not just a matter of the patient getting "information," it's about care. In the simple example you give, here, you provided the care need to assure safe treatment. GP is about treating the person in his or her complexity. Yes, it's about referral but it's also about wellness and the exams that pintpoint illnesses before they become severe. And in complex cases it is the GP who is, as another said, the conductor who coordinates for the patient and focuses everything on patient needs. In Canada at least the GP (or family medicine, or internal specialist) is the gatekeeper. His diagnoses lead to referrals, his RX pad is what keeps chronicity at bay. And the problems are interesting, is this rash important or not? And if not, why not a bit of hydrocortosone? Is the pain of the patient with osteoarthritis well managed (don't ask the orthopod) and if not, how can it be handled while awaiting surgery? And...this patient with a history of type II diabetes who is now type I...can I get him or her into the diabetes management program and work with the endrocrologist not only on the diabetes but total care...watching for complications. GP is about diagnosis and about people and then treating the people one diagnoses both collaboratively (with the specialists) and indepedently. So...who could want more than that?
20/1/2012 2:47 PM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
davebergie wrote:
Heh heh. You'll be sucked down the plughole into general practice with the rest of us before too long.
20/1/2012 2:48 PM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
aabarcellos wrote:
i thought i would never be a GP as I scored high in tests and was offered jobs with profs and encouraged to continue with each speciality as i did them so I was told i would be a good surgeon , psychiatrist , paeds etc . That was 30 yrs ago - so glad I did general practice -- suited me . It is a great job and depends on what you need good luck
20/1/2012 6:11 PM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
The great part of all our specialities is the opportunity to help people and feel that you do something good for society, and speciality doesn't really matter, it' s a question of your preference
21/1/2012 6:51 AM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
Joseph Ana wrote:
I am surprised that in 2012, there are still hospital doctors that are so ignorant of the usefulness of GPs. I thought that GP training, practice, status and desirability had become so obvious to most people especially hospital consultants. Infact GPs have become ever so wanted since the escalation of superspecialisation and compartmentalisation of hospital specialisms. patients still need to know that they are seen as persons with disease condition and not as 'heart disease', 'gallstones', 'enlarged prostates', 'headaches', etc etc. the holistic care that GPs provide so evidently remains the conerstone of good medical practice as prescribed by the GMC (General Medical Council) in the UK and I dare say worldwide. Maybe the RCGP Public Affairs unit needs to do a bit more enlightenment of Hospital doctors and the public about the sterling work that GPs do. Where would the NHS be without GPs? Joseph Ana competing interest: I specialised in General &Urological Surgery before transforming to become a GP. I have recently 2004-2008 used my skills as a GP to successfully serve as Chief Executive of a Ministryof Health in a large country in subsaharan Africa. If I went to the post straight from being a hospital consultant surgeon / urologist, I would have under performed as my predecessors did ( reference my book on the experience: 'whole ystem change of failing health systems'. 2009. published by BMJ West Africa Edition- www.bmjwestafrica.com).
21/1/2012 11:49 AM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
summerdaisy wrote:
It does seem to be seen as a fall back, which is dreadful; talented medical students should look at being a GP as a avenue to challenge themselves and make a huge difference to the lives of patients. From the (admittedly, limited) view I have had so far during my four years at medical school, it seems that it is difficult to be an exceptional GP, but worth it for what you can get out of it.
21/1/2012 6:24 PM GMT on bmj.com
 1 2 >> Last