What do you think?

Most popular blogs

Latest blog posts

Blog Image
Blogs by the online BMJ respiratory medicine champion
New hope for Sputum Cytology? *cough cough*
One perusing 'the paper' in the Drs Mess this morning, following the ward round, I found a small article entitled "I coughed up my incurable cancer".  It turns out that a woman of 37 had a severe coughing fit, and coughed up a 2cm "heart shaped" lump.  She took it to her GP, who sent it to the path lab, to be told it was an "aggresive  tumour".  She was then told to save for her funeral!

CT scanning revealed - nothing.  So she's been told that "It is very uncommon to cough up cancer, but she did".

Of course, I want to know more!  What was the pathology?  Was this likely to be an oropharyngeal mass, or lung?  Or oesophageal?  The Sun doesn't reveal the juicy details.  

The wee photo on the page describes the lady as "Lucky...." I should say so.  Quick straw poll of the Mess: no-one recalls anyone coughing up a tumour, although I have had patients cough up tracheal stents I spent so long carefully inserting.

I was teaching the students yesterday about screening for lung cancer, and the Fleischner guidence on SPNs - they asked me about sputum cytology, so I proclaimed it to be essentially useless.  I suspect the cytology on this occasion might have been positive.  Not sure if I can start advocating sputum *histology*....
Tags:
Email this post
User Image
Odysseus wrote:
I have seen this personally on several occasions; lung cancers previously undiagnosed.

In the antipodeans we spit in a clockwise direction like our cyclones and water down the bath plug. I have yet to see a tumour like this with a left hand thread.
12/1/2012 1:19 AM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
Odysseus wrote:
Somewhat tangential to this post but about lung cancer, I was on for ICU one weekend when a man was admitted having crashed his single engine plane in a swamp. I bronchoscoped him as I thought he may have aspirated (abnormal chest film) only to find fungating tumour arising from the RMB and up to the lower trachea. I think this is why he crashed.
12/1/2012 1:35 AM GMT on bmj.com
User Image
DrMK wrote:
Like you I saw this and presumed she coughed up a lump of stuff that had something you could make a cytological diagnosis on - not really that she had coughed up her cancer. Which I am sorry to say I don't quite believe. I believe your patients cough up stents sometimes. Mine used to breathe out their chest drains on occassion.
20/3/2012 10:49 AM GMT on bmj.com
Most Recent Tags